Israel/Palestine admin on 06 Jul 2005 01:11 pm
Behind the Walls
Today was the day that I have been long awaiting. I am still in so much shock at what I have seen, it seems difficult to explain what has happened. I knew before coming on this trip that I could not leave Israel without going and seeing the other side. Especially after spending the last 5 days here in West Jerusalem it seemed all the more imperative. I have found myself slipping into asking questions as to why the Palestinians would committ terrorist attacks. I mean from what we have seen, it is really not all that bad here. I guess, in that sense I have started to think that it is pretty good here; then today struck me. I would challenge you, that as you read my experience, let it penetrate and question and assumptions and opinoins you have. What you think you might know about Israel and the conflict here, lay that aside for the minute and just listen. At the same extent, remember this was just from what I have seen, there is also another side and balance is everything here in this land.
Early this morning we caught a bus into East Jerusalem and met up with a Palestinian man whom Nomi worked for last year. We drove with him into Palestine and then stayed the day there. Going through the checkpoint was interesting, the guards were intense and really wanted to ensure that we were going as tourists. It was certainly intimidating. Once we got into Bethleham we headed into the main market and toured the Church of the Nativity. On a side note, it was a fantastic site to see the birthplace of Christ and the oldest church in the world, which is over 1300 years old. After we were done with that, we wandered around the city going through neighborhoods and just observing the dynamics of this place.
At the initial glance, it was clear that this area is dying. THe main road, or what used to be the main road has been redirected about 300 meters in order for the Israeli’s to make security walls for a Holy Site, Rachels Tomb. So the main road had to be moved. Well by doing this and moving all the traffic, every business on the main road went out of business, over 250 of them. I looked down this street, that obviously used to be the hustle and bustle and saw it dead, hardly any cars and no people. The building on our left, about 6 stories, was completely vacated. You could see all the bullet holes and even places were apache helicopters had shot rockets into it. We were told that just 4 years ago the Israelis rolled their tanks down this road and were just shooting at the refugee camps, this was clearly evident.
Then we walked up to the wall. Isreal is building this wall for security. It is MASSIVE. As I stood next to it, it completely dwarfed me. Honestly it made me feel like I was in a prison. Ironically, that is what it is. Palestinians are rarely allowed to leave the city and are holled up with little view of teh outside world. Although I believe in the wall and the fact that it is being built, it is the way that Israel goes about it, that I disagree. As we entered Bethleham, it was clear that Israel had ’snaked’ the wall in order to swallow up the agricultural land outside the city. This is Palestinian land that they are taking, and it is the best land. So what is happening is Israel is making a Palestinian state with its wall. But this will not be a viable state. Isreal is taking all the agriculture and running the wall right through villages and towns in order to divide and weaken them. It is unbelievable to see this with your own eyes. As we walked back to the Bethleham, away from the wall, we noticed an apartment style building that had been taken over by the Isrealis and was being used as a military base in which they placed camoflauge and snipers on it to protect Rachels tomb.
In all, the dehumanization and injustice that is occuring here is unbelievable. Even more shocking was that yesterday we went to the World’s second largest Hollocaust museum. We saw how bad Jews had it in Germany before the final solution and they were killed. What I mean, is that in the 1930’s they had many of their rights and privilages taken away. Economically, they were restricted and their lives became nothing more than simply breathing. We all mourn this fact and recognize its injustice. However, I saw the same thing today. Israel has done the same thing with the Palestinians. Yes, I recognize that Isreal is begining to acknowledge them as people and their right to exist. Most Isreali’s believe in a Palestinian state, it is just that it is taking so long and their is so much disagreement about how it will proceed.
Looking back, I cant believe that we as North Americans never get the real story. How come the news doesnt cover the wall, they only cover terrorist attacks. The things we saw and experienced today I have never seen or heard anywhere else. I must say that my opinion is completely altered and my view changed. I still believe in Isreal and their right to this land, but their occupation of Palestine must end, for it is a crime against humanity.
Tomorrow morning we leave for Cairo and I am getting very sick. I wont have access to a computer for a long time, but still look for the random blog.
on 06 Jul 2005 at 9:00 pm # Tracy Carter
Jay,
so sorry that I have not emailed you. I have been so busy…plus you heard about my “cool” trip to Chicago. Novak took care of me though. I finally caught up to date and have read all of your blog…I actually ready all the stories outloud to Dyl. It was so fun to read all of your adventures. I am excited to see you soon and hear about all of the stories in person. First of all I LOVE sangria and tapas but I bet they taste better in Spain. I find your experience in Morroco priceless. I have heard stories of tourists being taken advantage of there so I think you hit the jackpot. I am not suprised for you to find Palestine as you have. Now you have a broader view of the world and will be able to understand how someone from France can side with Palestine and maybe even see how they may not know the whole story about Israel either. There is always more than one story to tell. Well we are all moved in and LOVING it. Our new-old house completely rocks and we have done some excellent improvements. Oh, Jacob is “fixin” to walk. He is working on some new moves and it is cute. We are preparing to come to Kelowna. Dyl is going to build a new front porch first and then mom comes. Then we come. So soon..but it will feel longer to you since you are having many adventures. Plus time stands still when you are in a foreign land. Tell Bustons hello and I am glad that he is the one who is your travel partner and faithful friend. I am sure Dylan will see him at UMKC in the fall. We will be praying that your sickness leaves quickly and you can enjoy all your plans to the fullest. Love ya.
Tracy
on 06 Jul 2005 at 9:42 pm # Aaron
Jamie, So I spent some time this evening and I finally got caught up on all your blogs. You write a lot. Anyway, I will check more regularly for updates. However, reading this current post, it appears to me that the Palestines did not make claim to the land until the Jews had returned and made it arable (sp?). There is no people group called “Palestines”, their late leader was a KGB trained Egyptian terrorist and actively kept them in poverty to ensure that they would sucide bomb the Jews. When Israel was formed they invited the Arabs to stay, but they left because they could not live with the Jews. The current situation rests with them and their hatred of the Jews. Furthermore, Israel is what it is today because of the Jews who immigrated their after the Holocaust. I am sure this view cause the blood to boil in some of your loyal readers, but I do not care. I will stop ranting now. I look forward to seeing you whenever, I am supposed to pick you up.
on 07 Jul 2005 at 12:57 am # nomi
As a local i feel compelled to say that it is dangerous to view anything in the region as black and white. it is dangerous to view Palestinian grief through the view of the Holocaust, to belittle what happened in the Holocaust by comparison, or belittle what is happening to the Palestinians. Things here dont happen for no reason. if there are bullet holes in a building, it is likely that militants chose that as a site from which they can shoot at Israeli neighbourhoods. the one thing that is sure in this region is retaliation- from both sides. it comes either in the form of suicide bombers or militant action taken by the Israeli Defence force. Both see themselves as justified. neither side is right, wrong, justified, victim, victimizer. it all meshes into one big gray scinerio where one is both victim and victimizer. One day in the Bethlahem doesnt give the full picture, and neither does one day in West Jerusalem. Please try not to form opinions. for those of us who have been here for a long time, we hardly know what the believe anymore- precisely because its never black and white.
on 07 Jul 2005 at 1:01 am # nomi
As a local i feel compelled to say that it is dangerous to view anything in the region as black and white. it is dangerous to view Palestinian grief through the lens of the Holocaust; to belittle what happened in the Holocaust by comparison, or belittle what is happening to the Palestinians because it doesnt compare to past Jewish grief. Pain and suffering stand on their own- in their own circumstances and should not be belittled by comparative games. Things here dont happen for no reason. if there are bullet holes in a building, it is likely that Palestinian militants chose that as a site from which they can shoot at Israeli neighbourhoods, and in response the Israeli army retaliated. who starts the ball rolling? Both sides. the one thing that is sure in this region is retaliation- from both sides. it comes either in the form of suicide bombers or militant action taken by the Israeli Defence force. Both see themselves as justified. but neither side is right, wrong, justified, victim, victimizer. it all meshes into one big gray scinerio where one is both victim and victimizer. One day in the Bethlahem doesnt give the full picture, and neither does one day in West Jerusalem. Please try not to form opinions. for those of us who have been here for a long time, we hardly know what the believe anymore- precisely because its never black and white, and the more you know and see, the less you understand.
on 07 Jul 2005 at 1:03 am # nomi
sorry, for leaving that twice. the second comment is edited.
on 08 Jul 2005 at 12:14 am # ashley
wow that sounds like you had such a good eye opening experience. sometimes it’s hard to feel connected to events in other parts of the world if you haven’t been there or if there’s no connection. i took a history course entirely on the holocaust so remember everything you saw! hope you feel better!